Thursday, December 22, 2011

EU breaks its own ruling on water hydration claims - Update

EU officials could be prosecuted after falling foul of their own ruling that banned claims that drinking water could prevent dehydration. The EU was widely derided last month for the bizarre decision to prohibit drinks companies from claiming drinking water could help avoid dehydration. Manufacturers face two years in jail for breaching the edict that was due to come into force this month after being passed in November.

But the EU could now be investigated after it emerged its Milk Programme was found to promote the health benefits of drinking water. The literature for the scheme, which encourages children to drink more milk, said: "You may not have known, but a large part of milk is actually water. So, if you regularly drink milk, you can stay hydrated at the same time.



“When people do not get enough water, a condition called ‘dehydration’, they can become tired, irritable and have a hard time concentrating. Drinking milk can help put the necessary water back into the body, while providing carbohydrates, proteins and other nutrients to give you energy.” A British MEP has called on the Procureur-General in Brussels to act on the blunder.

In his complaint, Paul Nuttall, Ukip member for North West England, said it was a "disgraceful breach of EU law by the European Commission." He added: "These people think that they can lay down the law that they have created no matter how absurd and threaten individuals and businesses with criminal sanctions. In this case, though, It appears that the EU just doesn't know its backside from its elbow."

Previously.

2 comments:

Gareth said...

The ruling was not as simple as you make out. The ruling was that makers of bottled water could not state or imply that only bottled water could be used for hydration. Which is fair enough. I don't drink water, bottled or tap. Or rather I don't drink it as it comes. Indeed I hardly drink anything other than coffee and the occasional Guinness and I'm not dehydrated.

Anonymous said...

If you are dehydrated, a bottle of Evian is not necessarily enough to fix that.
I think that's what the advice (and it was advice, rather than a law) was getting at.